Saturday, July 20, 2013

A Challenge to Goldman on Tesla's Value

On Tuesday, Goldman Sachs came out and urged investors to curb their enthusiasm for Tesla (TSLA), the electric carmaker and Bloomberg Businessweek cover subject whose shares had more than tripled this year.
Citing “sustainability of demand longer term” as a risk, Patrick Archambault, Goldman’s auto analyst, set a target price of 84, the average of three scenarios he saw playing out. That figure was way lower than Tesla’s previous close of just over 127. The shares responded by falling as much as 15 percent, the most in more than 18 months, on more than triple their average volume. Goldman has cred on Tesla; it was one of the banks that took the company public three years ago.
The very next day, Andrea James of Minneapolis-based Dougherty & Co. stepped up to the mic to counter the Wall Street giant. She wrote: “We ultimately believe that Tesla is a $300 stock at the factory’s maximum capacity, which we hair-cut to $200 for the execution risk.” (She previously had a $90 target). Tesla, she noted “makes the best product in an industry that does $1.5 trillion in sales. Just 2 percent market share on [its next-generation car] returns a $200 stock.”
James underscored that Tesla benefits from a technology company’s cost curve. Battery technology innovation is such that, in 10 years, the battery will be twice as good, at either half the price or twice the range. “For an electric vehicle,” she explained, “the cost to go a mile is tied to 1) electricity prices, which are regulated and tend to hold steady, and 2) performance of the electric battery pack, which is declining in cost over time. Thus, the cost to go a mile works in Tesla’s and the consumer’s favor. Win‐win.” James says that in the three years that she’s been following Tesla, the company’s cost per kilowatt hour has already fallen roughly in half.
She believes that Tesla’s Model S is on track to finish the year with gross margins of 25 percent—and without the benefit of regulatory credits. Not only does she see that margin rising, but she thinks that after 2017, Tesla will have scaled enough of a learning curve with the Model S to sell a lower-cost car (at $30,000 to $40,000) at a 25 percent margin. This Gen III Tesla, she writes, “should appeal greatly to younger people. We expect Gen III adoption to move even more quickly than that of the Model S. The Gen III will be an aspirational car for a new generation of car buyers.”
James’s analysis gets really interesting when she crunches numbers on the earnings potential of Tesla’s California factory. She notes that at its present configuration, Tesla can do 40,000 units per year there at peak efficiency—and 50,000 units per year if it kicks in a further $20 million to $40 million in capital spending. James believes Tesla can further expand the factory to be able to churn out 500,000 cars a year (which, she notes, would still represent less than 1 percent global market share on vehicles sold). “If we assume the stock is worth 20 times the [$15 a share] earnings potential of the factory,” she writes, “it makes Tesla a $300 stock and a $40 billion market cap.” For added intrigue, James notes that chief executive Elon Musk’s options are not fully vested until Tesla reaches a $43.2 billion market cap.
Tesla shares ended the day up 10 percent.
Take that, Goldman.

Friday, July 19, 2013

Can This Startup Help Freelancers Earn More?

Profiting by connecting employers with temporary workers goes back at least as far as the staffing agencies that gained prominence after World War II. With the ranks of independent workers in the U.S. estimated(PDF) to grow to more than 23 million within the next five years, a slew of startups have been seeking to tap into the freelance economy. One popular business model: pushing services that companies use to hire,manage, and pay freelance workers directly, as opposed to the intermediary role played by staffing firms likeManpower (MAN) and Kelly Services (KELYA).
Among recent entrants is Work Market. Like fellow marketplaces Elance and oDesk, the New York-based startup serves as a meeting place for employers and workers. And similar to staffing firms, Work Market handles human resources functions like background checks, accounting, and compliance needs for employers. That makes the company a good fit for both freelancers, who can earn more than at a temp agency, and employers that have complex hiring rules, says Chief Executive Officer Jeff Leventhal.
“It’s one thing to find one person to design a logo or deliver doughnuts,” says Leventhal, adding that the majority of the jobs posted to Work Market are for skilled workers in IT and legal services. “If you’re a big company, you need to build a process around finding, verifying, and paying freelance workers.”
Leventhal launched Work Market in 2011, keeping the company mostly under the radar while it signed large clients and tailored its system to each client’s human resources software. Today the company has more than 300 corporate clients, including defense contractorLockheed Martin (LMT) and marketing conglomerateOmnicom Group (OMC). More than 300 companies and 41,000 workers belong to the marketplace, and there are usually more than 2,500 open listings, the company says.
That’s a far cry from the 3.1 million registered freelancers that oDesk claims. To help reach more workers, Leventhal launched a service called Work Feed, which lets other websites publish job listings that appear on Work Market’s website. A recent adopter of Work Market’s job stream is Freelancers Union, whichadded Work Feed to its website yesterday.
Work Market is making the process of hiring freelancers more efficient, says Sara Horowitz, executive director at the nonprofit, leading to better pay. “A business may be paying $100 an hour for freelance labor,” she says. “But a payroll company takes this much, and a compliance company takes that, and by the time the worker gets paid, they may only be making $20 an hour.”
Work Market charges small clients a fee for each transaction. Larger employers pay a monthly fee of up to $10,000. The company, which raised $10 million in venture capital from SoftBank Capital, Spark Capital, and Union Square Ventures in May, is working on adding a free option for small businesses looking for freelance employees. The theory is that small firms will attract new talent that will be attractive to paying customers.
Leventhal says his 38-employee company isn’t profitable yet. He notes that it has enough clients to be in the black if it wasn’t spending to attract more employers and lay groundwork for expansion to Canada, India, Singapore, and Spain. For now, Freelancers Union’s Horowitz says Work Market is a step toward giving workers a transparent view of employers’ freelance costs. “Employers have been arguing that they need greater flexibility, and we think that’s true,” she says. “The problem is, that flexibility has always been at great cost to the freelancer. We need to look behind the label.”
Clark is a reporter for Bloomberg Businessweek covering small business and entrepreneurship.

Can an Algorithm Replace Stock Analysts?

As a journalist, I naturally regard the Chicago-based Narrative Science with morbid fascination. In 2010 the startup made news selling software that read baseball box scores and generated newspaper articles from the data. Narrative Science says the idea isn’t to put reporters out of work, but to extend their reach to events that would otherwise go uncovered. That didn’t stop Bloomberg Businessweek from asking whether sportswriters were really necessary.
And not just sportswriters. The company’s technology, called Quill, can also render stories from crime stats, medical studies, and survey data. Forbes publishes Narrative Science stories based on public companies’financial statements. Now the company says it doesn’t just want to do the job of business journalists, but also the work done by financial analysts.
At yesterday’s demo day for the FinTech Innovation Lab, a New York-based program that matches tech startups with mentors from the banking industry, Narrative Science Chief Technology Officer Kris Hammond said the software could turn data into written reports for wealth management firms, institutional investors, and research shops. “The target is to take the best financial adviser or analyst and turn his skill set into something that the machine is doing,” Hammond says.
Are financial firms buying in? Convincing a newspaper to run a computer-generated sports story is one thing, but asking investors and advisers to trust machine-written language seems like a harder sell. Maybe not, says Hammond. One-third of Narrative Science’s 50 clients are in financial services—Hammond declined to name names—and the company is shifting its focus away from media and toward finance. (Narrative Science also raised venture capital recently from In-Q-Tel, which invests on behalf of the Central Intelligence Agency.)
Wall Street already trusts computers to trade millions of dollars worth of securities on their own, so using an algorithm to put the numbers into words might not be a giant leap. Does that mean financial analysts should be as worried about their jobs as sportswriters? “We’ve had, I wouldn’t say zero, but close to zero pushback from analysts afraid of losing their jobs,” Hammond says. “Most of them see it as a way to spend their time working with the high end of their skill set and letting the machine take care of the lower end.”
Clark is a reporter for Bloomberg Businessweek covering small business and entrepreneurship.